Obsessive sleuthing

Arwa Mahdawi searches for an ending

Today: Arwa Mahdawi, Guardian columnist and the author of Strong Female Lead.


Issue No. 251

How to Solve a Murder: A Five-Part Guide
Arwa Mahdawi


How to Solve a Murder: A Five-Part Guide

by Arwa Mahdawi

Image of flyer: MISSING PERSON with photo of Susan Walsh, "Susan Walsh, Blond Hair, Blue Eyes, 36 Years old, 5'6" Tall, 100-110 lbs., Last Seen - Tues, July 16, 1996 11AM-12PM,, Washington Ave, Nutley NJ, Please contact the Nutley Police Dept., (201) 284-4940 with any information, Reward if found."

Part One: Start digging  

You don’t write true crime, you steal it. It doesn’t matter how well it’s told, or how thoroughly it’s investigated, every tale of true crime is someone else’s story. This one begins on a summer day in New Jersey in 1996 when a woman called Susan Walsh went out to make a phone call. She left her house around noon and she never came back.

Susan was 36 when she disappeared, the same age I was when I first learned about her. Like me, she was also a freelance journalist, and I became intrigued by her writing; she’d been building a name for herself at the Village Voice, where she’d broken a front-page story about the Russian mob trafficking go-go dancers to New Jersey. When she went missing she’d also been working on a piece about people in the vampire fetish scene who were stealing blood from New York hospitals.

Keep us breathing fire!

just a few of our contributors

For $3/month you can read this whole post and get our weekdaily newsletter too!


You found the secret way to generate a gift link